Blizzard says it wants to “get rid” of best-in-slot gear in World of Warcraft: Forever, with senior game designer Aidan Moon arguing that itemisation should reward situational choices instead of one fixed endgame list. The comments came in the latest official World of Warcraft: Forever podcast, as the game’s first raids get ready to launch in early December.
Moon was direct about the studio’s goal. “I essentially want to get rid of BIS,” he said. He added that he does not think BiS is good for “a video game that’s supposed to be about role-playing.” Blizzard’s answer is a set of systems built around creature subtypes and biomes, so the value of a piece of gear can change depending on where it is used and what the player is fighting.
Blizzard’s itemisation plan
In Moon’s view, best-in-slot thinking gives players one universal answer for every slot and every encounter. That has long been part of World of Warcraft raiding, where players compare drops, build theorycrafted lists and chase specific items to replace the gear they already have. Blizzard now wants Forever to push in the opposite direction.
Moon pointed to gear that works better against specific enemy groups, such as murlocs, as one part of the plan. “That’s why I’ve introduced the creature subtype system,” he said. He also said Blizzard has introduced a biome system, with item strength tied to the area and encounter being faced.
The design leaves room for different kinds of players. Some will still optimise around a boss-by-boss list, while others may stick to gear that is broadly strong across a raid. Moon’s pitch is not that every player must carry a different set for every pull, but that the game should make that option matter if people want to pursue it.
The current moment makes that especially visible. The most dedicated World of Warcraft: Forever players are already reaching max level, or getting close to it, and many are hunting for raid-ready items before the next tier opens. That is exactly the habit Blizzard is trying to complicate, not remove entirely.
Barrow Deeps will change by wing
Moon used the upcoming Barrow Deeps raid as the clearest example of how the system will work. He said the raid will be split into different biomes, with distinct sections that create different gear opportunities. “If you go to the left wing that’s snowy; if you go to the right wing, that’s haunted; if you go down below, that’s cavernous,” he said.
That structure means the same item may not stay ideal from one boss to the next. Moon said, “I think your BIS should be different for every single boss if you’re making a theoretical BIS list.” In practice, that suggests a piece that performs well in one biome may lose value a few pulls later if the surroundings or enemy type change.
This is a break from the more familiar vertical progression in World of Warcraft, where players usually move toward clearly stronger drops as they go deeper into raids. In Forever, Blizzard appears to want gear to shift sideways as well as upward, so the best loadout depends more on context than on a single ranking.
- Creature subtype gear is meant to perform better against specific enemy types.
- Biome bonuses will vary by section of the raid.
- Barrow Deeps includes snowy, haunted and cavernous wings.
- Players can still choose between niche gear and generally strong gear.
Chase items will still keep people running raids
Moon also talked about chase items, meaning rewards with especially low drop rates that keep players returning to raids over time. He said Barrow Deeps will continue to include several such items, which he hopes will keep players coming back to it for years.
The items Moon is likely referring to include mounts, pets, situational gear and perhaps campfire bonuses. Those rewards are not all simple power upgrades. Some are useful because they fit a specific raid setup or encounter, which makes them harder to place on a standard best-in-slot list.
The campfire example from the article shows how specific those rewards can be. One player example described an upgraded campfire that allows a greater campfire to be built, with more buff items placed around it. The result is a tool that can be useful to a raid composition without being the sort of thing players usually think of when they build a BiS list.
Blizzard’s wider raid design has already leaned into that kind of specialisation. Items with unusual bonuses, rare drops and encounter-specific value are part of the same approach Moon outlined on the podcast, where the goal is to make players think about the encounter in front of them rather than a fixed list copied from somewhere else.
Players are already building raid plans
That debate is arriving just as raid preparation is speeding up. As GAMER2GO reported previously, Blizzard has been lining up December 1 updates, and the next wave of Forever content is close enough that players are already planning ahead. The first raid tier is the next big test for the game’s itemisation rules.
Best-in-slot planning is especially active because the most dedicated players are reaching max level, or nearing it, and are already sorting gear for the raid ahead. Some are using checklists and theorycrafted loadouts now, even as Blizzard says it wants players to think less about one fixed “best” set and more about what each encounter rewards.
The likely result is not the disappearance of gearing math, but a messier version of it. Players may still chase broadly accepted strong items, while also collecting side pieces that become valuable in certain biomes, against certain enemy types, or in a specific boss room. Blizzard’s system gives more room for that kind of split between general power and narrow utility.
World of Warcraft: Forever has been one of Blizzard’s strongest recent launches. The game broke franchise records on release in early November, and it now has more weekly players than World of Warcraft has seen in 15 years. That popularity is one reason this itemisation shift matters so much: the first raids will show whether players embrace a system built around context instead of one perfect list.
i kind of get what they mean with the creature subtype stuff, but it’s gonna be weird if my gear score is fine and the item is still bad because the room is haunted or snowy. that does sound more like actual raid prep than just chasing one spreadsheet BiS though. if they pull it off, it might make loot feel less solved on day one and more like you’re building for the fight instead of the wowhead list.